Season 1

No. 20: Phillies at Cubs, May 17, 1979. The Phillies defeated the Cubs by a score of 23–22.

No. 19: Giants at Marlins, October 4, 2003

No. 18: Phillies at Astros, October 12, 1980

No. 17: Yankees at Red Sox, October 17, 2004. The Yankee collapse in the 2004 ALCS begins.

No. 16: Tigers at Twins, October 6, 2009

No. 15: Yankees at Mariners, October 8, 1995 “The Double” – Baseball Hall-of-Famer Ken Griffey, Jr. scores from first base on fellow Hall-of-Famer Edgar Martinez’s double in the bottom of the 11th inning that clinched the series for Seattle.

No. 14: Phillies at Blue Jays, October 23, 1993

No. 13: Indians at Marlins, October 26, 1997

No. 12: Diamondbacks at Yankees, October 31, 2001

No. 11: Yankees at Red Sox, October 2, 1978

No. 10: Athletics at Dodgers, October 15, 1988 Kirk Gibson creates one of MLB’s most legendary moments as his pinch-hit walk-off home run gives the Dodgers a Game 1 victory.

No. 9: Yankees at Diamondbacks, November 4, 2001

No. 8: Red Sox at Angels, October 12, 1986

No. 7: Marlins at Cubs, October 14, 2003: "The Bartman Game."

No. 6: Red Sox at Yankees, October 16, 2003: Aaron Boone’s 11th inning walk-off home run sends the Yankees to the World Series while eliminating their rival Red Sox.

No. 5: Mets at Astros, October 15, 1986

No. 4: Pirates at Braves, October 14, 1992

No. 3: Red Sox at Mets, October 25, 1986. Guests Mookie Wilson, Bob Ojeda, and Bill Buckner recount Game 6 of the 1986 World Series, which ended in an improbable tenth-inning rally punctuated by the most famous fielding error of the last 100 years.

The 2nd best game in MLB history based on votes from an expert panel and MLB Network viewers.

No. 1: Reds at Red Sox, October 21, 1975